For most of New York’s history, a house titled in one person’s name could pass at death in only a few ways: by will through probate, by intestacy through administration, or through a trust or joint ownership arranged during life. That changed when Real Property Law § 424 took effect on July 19, 2024. New York now permits a transfer on death deed, sometimes called a TOD deed, which names one or more beneficiaries who take the property when the owner dies, without the house passing through the probate estate.
The statute is useful, but it has strict execution rules, leaves the property exposed to estate creditors for a period, and can be challenged like a will.
What a Transfer on Death Deed Does
Under RPL § 424, an individual may transfer real property to one or more beneficiaries effective at the transferor’s death. The deed is expressly nontestamentary. It is not a will, and the property passes outside probate.
During the owner’s lifetime, the deed does essentially nothing. The statute provides that a TOD deed does not affect the owner’s right to sell or mortgage the property, does not affect the rights of the owner’s creditors, and creates no legal or equitable interest in the named beneficiary. The beneficiary does not need to be told about the deed, does not need to accept it, and gives no consideration for it.
That is the main attraction. Unlike adding a child to the deed as a joint owner, a TOD deed gives the child no present interest and does not require the child’s signature to sell or refinance.
How the Deed Must Be Signed and Recorded
The execution requirements are where these deeds succeed or fail. The statute requires that a TOD deed:
- contain the essential elements and formalities of a properly recordable lifetime deed;
- state that the transfer to the beneficiary is to occur at the transferor’s death;
- be signed by two witnesses who were present at the same time; and
- be acknowledged before a notary.
The deed must also be recorded in the county clerk’s office before the owner dies. For property on the East End and elsewhere in Suffolk County, that means the Suffolk County Clerk. A deed that is signed but sitting in a drawer at death does not work.
The statute requires the same mental capacity to make or revoke a TOD deed as to make a will. That standard matters later if anyone challenges the deed.
Revoking or Changing a TOD Deed
A TOD deed is revocable even if the deed itself says otherwise. But once it is recorded, the owner cannot revoke it by tearing it up or writing “void” across it. The statute allows revocation only by a later recorded instrument: a new TOD deed that revokes the earlier one expressly or by inconsistency, a recorded instrument of revocation, or a lifetime deed that expressly revokes it.
A will does not revoke a TOD deed. The statutory form’s own instructions say so directly. If a later will leaves “my house” to someone else, the recorded deed still controls unless it has been properly revoked of record.
Where the property is owned jointly, revocation by one owner does not affect the other owners’ interests, and a deed signed by joint owners is revoked only if all living joint owners revoke it. If a joint owner dies and other joint owners survive, the property passes to the survivors under the right of survivorship; the TOD deed takes effect only when the last joint owner dies.
What Happens at Death
When the owner dies, the property passes to the beneficiaries who survive the owner, subject to any mortgage, lien, or other encumbrance existing at death. The transfer is without warranty of title. If there are several beneficiaries, the statute provides that they take equal and undivided shares with no right of survivorship.
The statute also addresses a beneficiary who dies first: that beneficiary’s interest lapses. Where there are other named beneficiaries, the lapsed share passes to them. This is a different result from the anti-lapse rules that apply to certain gifts under a will, and it is one of the main reasons a TOD deed should be reviewed alongside the rest of the plan rather than signed in isolation. A deed naming one child, where that child dies before the parent, may leave the property back in the probate estate, and the grandchildren may not receive what the parent assumed they would.
A beneficiary may also renounce all or part of the interest, in the same manner as a beneficiary under a will.
Creditors and the Estate
A TOD deed avoids probate, but it does not insulate the property from the owner’s debts. If the probate estate is insufficient to pay allowed claims and statutory allowances, the statute permits the estate to enforce that liability against property transferred by a TOD deed. A proceeding to do so must be commenced no later than eighteen months after the owner’s death. If more than one property passed this way, the liability is apportioned by net value.
In practice, this means a beneficiary who receives a house by TOD deed should not assume the title is free of the estate’s obligations until that period has run, and a fiduciary dealing with an insolvent estate should look for TOD deeds of record. For background on how claims against an estate are presented and paid, see our earlier post on creditor claims in a New York estate.
TOD Deeds Can Still Be Challenged
Section 424 does not limit claims based on fraud, undue influence, duress, mistake, or other invalidating causes. A TOD deed signed by an elderly parent in favor of one child, shortly before death, can draw the same kinds of objections that a late-life will draws. The difference is procedural: because the deed is not probated, the dispute generally does not arise through probate objections, and the people challenging it must identify the right court and proceeding.
Divorce also matters. The statute provides that divorce or annulment affects a TOD deed as provided in EPTL 5-1.4, the statute that revokes certain dispositions to a former spouse. If you have been through a divorce, our post on updating an estate plan after divorce covers the broader picture.
When a TOD Deed Fits and When It Does Not
In our practice judgment, a TOD deed tends to fit best where:
- the owner holds a single New York property outright;
- the intended beneficiaries are adults who will get along as co-owners or will sell promptly;
- the rest of the estate is simple enough that avoiding probate on the house avoids a proceeding entirely; and
- there is no need for ongoing management, protection for a young or vulnerable beneficiary, or staged distributions.
It tends to fit poorly where the beneficiaries are minors, where one beneficiary needs protection from creditors or poor judgment, where several siblings will inherit a house one of them lives in, or where the owner wants detailed instructions about who may live in the property and who pays the carrying costs. Those situations usually call for a will with a testamentary trust or a revocable trust. Our post on funding a revocable trust explains why a trust only works if the deed actually goes into it.
For East End second-home owners, note that Section 424 governs New York real property only; see our post on estate planning for a Long Island second home.
Practical Points Before Signing
- Confirm how title is currently held. Where property is held jointly with a right of survivorship, including by spouses as tenants by the entirety, the surviving owner takes first and the TOD deed operates only at the death of the last surviving joint owner.
- Name beneficiaries with care and think through what happens if one dies first.
- Coordinate the deed with the will, beneficiary designations, and any trust. The deed will control the property regardless of what the will says.
- Use the statutory form or a deed that meets every element of the statute, with two witnesses present together and a notary.
- Record it promptly and keep the recorded copy with the rest of the estate plan.
- Do not use a TOD deed to resolve a family disagreement. It invites the challenge it was meant to avoid.
Next Steps
A transfer on death deed is a tool, not a plan. It can save a family a probate proceeding, or it can create a title problem and a lawsuit, depending on how it fits with everything else. If you are considering one for property in Suffolk County or elsewhere on Long Island, our estate planning practice can review how your property is titled and whether a TOD deed, a will, or a trust makes more sense. You can read William G. Goode’s attorney profile or contact the office to schedule a consultation.
Five Frequently Asked Questions
Does a transfer on death deed avoid probate in New York?
Yes, as to the property it covers. RPL § 424 makes the transfer nontestamentary, so the property passes outside probate. Other assets in the estate may still require a proceeding.
Can I revoke a TOD deed in my will?
No. Once recorded, a TOD deed can be revoked only by a later recorded instrument that meets the statute, such as a new TOD deed, a recorded revocation, or a lifetime deed that expressly revokes it.
Does my beneficiary need to sign or know about the deed?
No. The statute makes the deed effective without notice to, delivery to, or acceptance by the beneficiary during your lifetime.
What if my beneficiary dies before me?
That beneficiary’s interest lapses. If other beneficiaries are named, the lapsed share passes to them. If not, the property may end up in your estate.
Can creditors reach a house transferred by TOD deed?
Yes, in some circumstances. If the probate estate cannot pay allowed claims and statutory allowances, the estate may pursue the property, with a proceeding required within eighteen months after death.
Authorities
- Real Property Law § 424 — transfer on death deeds (execution, recording, revocation, effect at death, creditor liability, statutory forms); effective July 19, 2024.
- EPTL 5-1.4 — revocation of certain dispositions to a former spouse, applied to TOD deeds by RPL § 424(12)(b).
Disclaimer
Attorney Advertising — General Information: This article provides general information, not legal advice, and does not create an attorney-client relationship. Whether a transfer on death deed is appropriate depends on how your property is titled, your family circumstances, and the rest of your estate plan. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. The Law Office of William G. Goode, P.C. is responsible for this content.