Partition Actions in New York: When Co-Owners Cannot Agree on the Property

Co-ownership of real estate works until it does not. Siblings inherit a house in Hampton Bays and one wants to keep it while the others want to sell. Two business partners bought a building together and no longer speak. A former couple who never married still hold title to a house in Riverhead as tenants in common. In each case, the law does not force anyone to remain a co-owner indefinitely. The remedy is an action for partition under Article 9 of the Real Property Actions and Proceedings Law (RPAPL).

Partition is an old remedy, and much of it is governed by equitable principles developed in case law. But two statutory points shape almost every New York partition case today: who may bring the action under RPAPL 901, and whether the property is “heirs property” subject to the special procedures of RPAPL 993. This post covers both, along with practical considerations for Suffolk County and Long Island owners.

Who May Bring a Partition Action

RPAPL 901(1) allows a person who holds and is in possession of real property as a joint tenant or tenant in common, with an estate of inheritance, for life, or for years, to maintain an action for partition. The action may seek a physical division of the property, or a sale if it appears that partition cannot be made without great prejudice to the owners.

The statute also addresses situations that come up often in estate work:

  • An heir who is a joint tenant or tenant in common may bring the action whether or not in possession, even if the decedent made an apparent devise to someone else, but the plaintiff must establish that the apparent devise is void (RPAPL 901(3)).
  • An executor or administrator of an estate that owns property in common with others may bring or join a partition action, with the approval of the Surrogate on proper application (RPAPL 901(4)).
  • Holders of certain future interests may seek partition of their share, subject to the present estate, with limits on sale (RPAPL 901(2)).

Partition is generally not available to tenants by the entirety, who are spouses and hold title differently. That form of ownership is outside this discussion.

Division or Sale

The starting point under RPAPL 901(1) is physical partition. A sale is available when division cannot be made without great prejudice to the owners. On Long Island, a single-family house on one lot is rarely divisible in any practical sense, so most contested partition cases involving a residence end in a sale, a buyout, or a negotiated resolution.

Before reaching that point, however, the court must consider whether the Heirs Act applies.

The Heirs Property Act: RPAPL 993

New York adopted the Uniform Partition of Heirs Property Act as RPAPL 993. Where it applies, it changes the procedure significantly, and it is designed to slow forced sales of family property.

What Counts as Heirs Property

In summary, heirs property is real property held in a tenancy in common where there is no binding agreement among the co-tenants governing partition, at least one co-tenant acquired title from a relative, and the property is used for residential or agricultural purposes, along with at least one additional statutory condition, such as relatives holding a specified percentage of the interests. The statute’s definitions are precise, and whether a given property qualifies should be checked against the statutory text rather than assumed.

The statute directs the court, after notice and an opportunity to be heard, to determine whether the property is heirs property. If it is, the property must be partitioned under RPAPL 993 unless all of the co-tenants otherwise agree in a record. The statutory language is mandatory, so a co-owner cannot simply elect traditional partition when the criteria are met.

Mandatory Settlement Conference

Where the Heirs Act applies, the statute requires a settlement conference within sixty days after a request for judicial intervention is filed. The parties must negotiate in good faith, and the statute provides for dismissal if the court finds that the plaintiff did not. A plaintiff who files expecting a quick sale should understand that the court will first insist on a real attempt at settlement.

Valuation and the Right to Buy Out

The court determines fair market value by agreement of the parties, by an evidentiary hearing where an appraisal would not be cost-effective, or by a court-ordered appraisal from a disinterested licensed appraiser. A party may object to the appraisal within thirty days after notice of it.

If a co-tenant requests partition by sale, the other co-tenants may elect to buy that co-tenant’s interest at the determined value. The election must be made within forty-five days after notice of the value, and the purchase price is the value multiplied by the percentage interest being bought. For a family where one sibling wants to keep the house, this buyout right is often the most important part of the statute.

Preference for Division

Under the Heirs Act, the court must order partition in kind unless it would result in great manifest prejudice to the co-tenants as a group. The statute lists factors the court must weigh, including whether the property can practicably be divided, whether division would materially reduce its value compared with a sale of the whole, how long the family has owned it, sentimental and ancestral attachment, the current lawful use, and each co-tenant’s contributions to taxes, insurance, and upkeep. No single factor controls.

How a Sale Proceeds

If the court orders a sale, the default under RPAPL 993 is an open-market sale through a licensed real estate broker at a price no lower than the determined value, unless the court finds that sealed bids or an auction would be more economically advantageous for the co-tenants as a group. That differs from the traditional referee’s auction, which can produce a lower price.

Practical Issues in Partition Litigation

Beyond the statutes, several issues recur. In our experience:

  • Notice of pendency. Because a partition action affects title, the plaintiff commonly files a notice of pendency so the property cannot be sold or encumbered out from under the case. Our post on notices of pendency in New York real estate disputes explains how that works.
  • Accounting between co-owners. Disputes over who paid the taxes, mortgage, insurance, and repairs, and whether a co-owner in sole possession owes the others anything, are often argued as equitable adjustments within the partition case. These issues are fact-specific and frequently drive the economics more than the sale price.
  • Identifying every owner. All persons with an interest must be before the court. When title passed through an estate that was never administered, determining the current owners can require work in Surrogate’s Court first. Our post on identifying distributees in New York probate covers that process.
  • Estate-owned property. If the property is still in an open estate, the fiduciary may be able to sell it in the administration without a partition action. Our post on selling real estate during New York probate explains when that is possible.
  • Cost and time. Partition is rarely fast. Appraisals, conferences, motion practice, and the sale itself all take time and money that come out of the property’s value. A negotiated buyout is usually the better outcome when it is realistically available.

Getting Advice

Partition cases sit at the intersection of real property litigation and estate disputes, and many of them begin with a death in the family. If you co-own property in Suffolk County or elsewhere on Long Island and the co-owners cannot agree, it is worth understanding your rights before positions harden. The firm handles estate litigation and related property disputes in Supreme Court and Surrogate’s Court. You can review William G. Goode’s attorney profile or contact the office to discuss your situation.

Five Frequently Asked Questions

Can one co-owner force the sale of a house in New York?

Often, yes. A co-owner in possession may bring a partition action under RPAPL 901. A sale is ordered when physical division would cause great prejudice to the owners, subject to the Heirs Act where it applies.

What is heirs property under New York law?

Generally, tenancy-in-common property used for residential or agricultural purposes, with no partition agreement among the co-tenants, where at least one acquired title from a relative and additional statutory conditions are met.

Can I buy out my sibling instead of selling the whole house?

Under the Heirs Act, if a co-tenant requests a sale, the others may elect within forty-five days after notice of the court’s valuation to buy that interest at the determined value.

Can an executor bring a partition action?

Yes. RPAPL 901(4) allows an executor or administrator of an estate that owns property in common to bring or join a partition action with the Surrogate’s approval.

How is the sale price set in an heirs property case?

The court determines fair market value by agreement, by hearing, or by appraisal. An ordered sale is generally an open-market listing at no less than that value.

Authorities

  • RPAPL 901 — who may maintain a partition action; sale where partition would cause great prejudice.
  • RPAPL 993 — Uniform Partition of Heirs Property Act (determination, settlement conference, valuation, buyout, partition in kind, sale).

Disclaimer

Attorney Advertising — General Information: This article provides general information, not legal advice, and does not create an attorney-client relationship. Partition outcomes depend on title, the co-owners’ relationships and contributions, and the specific facts. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. The Law Office of William G. Goode, P.C. is responsible for this content.