A judgment is only as good as the defendant’s ability to pay it. In a collection case or business dispute, a creditor may have a strong claim and still end up with nothing if the defendant moves money out of reach while the case is pending. New York’s answer to that problem is the order of attachment under Article 62 of the Civil Practice Law and Rules (CPLR). An attachment allows the sheriff to levy on the defendant’s property before judgment, so that the property is held as security for whatever judgment the plaintiff eventually obtains.
Attachment is powerful, and New York courts treat it accordingly. The statute is strict, the plaintiff must post security, and a plaintiff who obtains an attachment that should not have issued can be liable for the defendant’s damages. This post walks through the grounds, the required showing, the procedure, and the practical judgment involved in deciding whether to seek one.
When Attachment Is Available
Under CPLR 6201, an order of attachment may be granted in any action, other than a matrimonial action, where the plaintiff has demanded and would be entitled to a money judgment against one or more defendants, when one of the statutory grounds exists. In summary, the grounds are:
- Nondomiciliary or unauthorized foreign corporation. The defendant is a nondomiciliary residing outside New York, or a foreign corporation not qualified to do business in the state.
- Defendant cannot be served. The defendant resides or is domiciled in New York and cannot be personally served despite diligent efforts.
- Fraudulent disposition. The defendant, with intent to defraud creditors or frustrate the enforcement of a judgment that might be rendered in the plaintiff’s favor, has assigned, disposed of, encumbered, or secreted property, or removed it from the state, or is about to do so.
- Crime victim claims. Certain actions by crime victims against the person convicted, under the Executive Law.
- Judgment-based claims. The cause of action is based on a judgment, decree, or order of a court of the United States or another court entitled to full faith and credit in New York, or on a judgment that qualifies for recognition under CPLR Article 53.
The statute uses the word “may.” Even when a ground exists, the court has discretion.
What the Plaintiff Must Show
CPLR 6212(a) requires the plaintiff to show, by affidavit and other written evidence:
- that there is a cause of action;
- that it is probable the plaintiff will succeed on the merits;
- that one or more grounds for attachment under CPLR 6201 exist; and
- that the amount demanded from the defendant exceeds all counterclaims known to the plaintiff.
In our practice judgment, the probability-of-success element is where many applications are won or lost. An affidavit that simply asserts the debt is owed, without the contract, invoices, account history, or a guaranty, is unlikely to carry the burden. The stronger the documentary proof of liability, the better the application. In commercial collection matters, the same documents that support an attachment often also support a motion for summary judgment in lieu of complaint under CPLR 3213 or a claim on a personal guaranty.
The Fraud Ground Requires Evidence of Intent
The fraudulent-disposition ground under CPLR 6201(3) is frequently invoked, and in our experience it is often the hardest to prove. The statute requires intent to defraud creditors or to frustrate enforcement of a judgment. Nonpayment of a debt, financial difficulty, or ordinary business transfers are not, by themselves, evidence of that intent. A plaintiff relying on this ground should be prepared with specific facts: transfers of assets to insiders for little or no value, sudden closing of accounts, listing of real property for sale after a demand was made, or similar conduct.
The Undertaking and the Plaintiff’s Exposure
Attachment is not free. Under CPLR 6212(b), the plaintiff must give an undertaking, in an amount fixed by the court but not less than five hundred dollars, conditioned on paying the defendant’s costs and damages, including reasonable attorney’s fees, if the defendant recovers judgment or it is finally decided that the plaintiff was not entitled to the attachment. The undertaking also covers the sheriff’s allowable fees.
More significantly, CPLR 6212(e) makes the plaintiff liable for those costs and damages, including reasonable attorney’s fees, and provides that the plaintiff’s liability is not limited by the amount of the undertaking. A wrongful attachment that freezes a business’s operating account can cause real damage, and the plaintiff bears that risk.
Procedure: With or Without Notice
An order of attachment may be sought on notice or without notice. When it is granted without notice, the order must require the plaintiff to move to confirm it within a short period after levy. Under CPLR 6211, that period may not exceed five days after levy, or ten days for an attachment based on the nondomiciliary or foreign corporation ground in CPLR 6201(1), with a limited possible extension. If the plaintiff does not move to confirm in time, the order of attachment and any levy under it have no further effect and must be vacated on motion.
Separately, CPLR 6212(c) requires the plaintiff, within ten days after the order is granted, to file the order, the supporting affidavit and papers, and the summons and complaint with the clerk. If the filing is not made in time, the order is invalid unless the time was extended.
These deadlines are short and unforgiving. An attachment application should not be filed until the confirmation motion can be made promptly.
The Defendant’s Response
A defendant, a garnishee such as a bank, or any person with an interest in the attached property may move under CPLR 6223 to vacate or modify the attachment before the property is applied to a judgment. On that motion, and on a motion to confirm, the plaintiff bears the burden of establishing the grounds for the attachment, the need for continuing the levy, and the probability of success on the merits.
CPLR 6223 also provides that, once the defendant has appeared in the action, the court must vacate the order if it determines that the attachment is unnecessary to the security of the plaintiff. For defendants, that provision can matter as much as a challenge on the merits.
How Attachment Differs From Other Remedies
Attachment is security for a future money judgment. It is different from:
- Judgment enforcement. Once a judgment is entered, the creditor uses CPLR Article 52 devices such as restraining notices, information subpoenas, and executions. Our post on enforcing a New York money judgment covers those tools.
- Preliminary injunctions. An injunction orders a party to do or not do something and is governed by different standards. Our post on preliminary injunctions and TROs in business disputes explains the distinction.
Practical Considerations
In our practice judgment, the decision to seek attachment usually turns on a few questions:
- Is there a real risk the defendant’s assets will disappear, or is the concern simply that the defendant is slow to pay?
- Can the plaintiff document liability well enough to show probable success?
- Does the plaintiff know where the assets are, so the sheriff’s levy will actually reach something?
- Is the plaintiff prepared to post an undertaking and accept liability for damages if the attachment is later vacated?
Where the answers support it, attachment can change the dynamics of a case quickly. Where they do not, it can create counterclaims and expense.
Getting Advice
Attachment is one of the more technical remedies in New York practice, and it rewards preparation. The firm represents businesses and individuals in Supreme Court in contract, collection, and commercial disputes on Long Island. To learn more about the firm’s business litigation practice, review William G. Goode’s attorney profile or contact the office.
Five Frequently Asked Questions
What is an order of attachment in New York?
A court order under CPLR Article 62 that allows the sheriff to levy on a defendant’s property before judgment, holding it as security for a money judgment the plaintiff may obtain.
Can I attach assets just because the defendant owes me money?
No. A statutory ground under CPLR 6201 must exist, such as the defendant being a nondomiciliary or having disposed of property with intent to defraud creditors.
Do I have to post a bond to get an attachment?
Yes. CPLR 6212(b) requires an undertaking in an amount fixed by the court, not less than five hundred dollars, and the plaintiff’s liability is not limited to that amount.
How quickly must an ex parte attachment be confirmed?
Within the period set in the order, which under CPLR 6211 may not exceed five days after levy, or ten days where the ground is CPLR 6201(1).
Can a defendant get an attachment vacated?
Yes. Under CPLR 6223, the plaintiff must establish the grounds, the need for continuing the levy, and probable success. The court must vacate if the attachment is unnecessary to secure the plaintiff after the defendant appears.
Authorities
- CPLR 6201 — grounds for attachment.
- CPLR 6211 — order of attachment without notice; motion to confirm.
- CPLR 6212 — required showing, undertaking, filing, and plaintiff’s liability for damages.
- CPLR 6223 — vacating or modifying an attachment; burden of proof.
Disclaimer
Attorney Advertising — General Information: This article provides general information, not legal advice, and does not create an attorney-client relationship. Whether an attachment is available or advisable depends on the parties, the evidence, and the specific facts. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. The Law Office of William G. Goode, P.C. is responsible for this content.